Following on from my post last week about the role of patron at Kickstarter, NPR has run a piece called, “When A Kickstarter Campaign Fails, Does Anyone Get The Money Back?” This appears to have nudged Kickstarter into responding with a blog post, “Accountability on Kickstarter.”
I suggest that you read or listen to NPR’s show before reading Kickstarter’s reply but one of the key statements Kickstarter makes on this matter is below.
Is a creator legally obligated to fulfill the promises of their project?
That’s great, but does it change anything in reality? Are you really going to take out legal action to recover $100? I think not. Kickstarter even points out that it feels that legal action is only appropriate if the creator has failed to make a good faith effort.
Consequently, I don’t think this changes anything. Kickstarter is still a great site, but go in with your eyes open as to the possible outcomes, especially the one where you lose all your cash.
Note that UK folk may have some protection if they paid for a failed project using a credit card under Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 as it appears to cover purchases outside of the UK too. I am not a lawyer, etc.
I like Kickstarter. It’s a world full of promise, where great ideas vie for money. I’ve pledged for a handful of projects, most of which met their funding targets and of those, all delivered on their promises. A few of the products weren’t as I expected but who hasn’t bought something that they later regretted?
For sure, it’s not always million dollar projects at Kickstarter. Plenty of projects fail to meet their targets and many of them rightly so. I’m not going to name names, but you don’t need to look very hard for projects that have no merit whatsoever (IMHO). Conversely, there are many worthwhile projects that don’t make the cut too.
But what of those projects that do get funded but don’t deliver on their promises? Fortunately, there haven’t been too many of them and while Kickstarter distances itself from the projects themselves, it encourages project owners to return the funding if the project gets into difficulties. But there are no guarantees…if the money is gone, it’s gone.
In a consumer and customer-oriented world, an older world perhaps more accurately describes our role. Patron.
From Oxford Dictionaries, definition of a patron:
1. a person who gives financial or other support to a person, organization, or cause: a celebrated patron of the arts
The definition makes no mention of reward or goods and it’s easier to comprehend with the more artistic projects on Kickstarter given the historical context of the term. Regardless, it applies equally well to the technological ones in that there might be a hope of a product at the end of the project but there is no certainty.
Don’t get me wrong – I like Kickstarter and will continue to support projects there. However people need to understand the risks. At the moment, Kickstarter occupies a useful unregulated niche but I fear that a few high-profile failures losing millions of dollars will draw it to the attention of the authorities and regulation. I sincerely hope that day won’t come, but until then, remember you are patron at Kickstarter.
Yes I am back… Back in the Saddle with my first change to the show format. Quantity does not always equal quality one of the first change I am implementing on the show is more quality versus quantity. I have been jamming more and more into the show. That change starts in today’s show where I refuse to rush, even though I have 10 articles left at the end of the show. From here on out you will get an even spread of content throughout the program and no more rush to jam in the last topics at the end. This will result in the show intro segment being tightened up as well in future shows. We also have a prize winner tonight as well.
$2.49 for one new or transfer .com @ GoDaddy Promo Code geek249
32% off total new order @ GoDaddy Promo Code go32off1
Subscribe Today: Audio | Video | iTunes | Zune
Download the Show File
Follow @geeknews on Twitter
Geek News Central Facebook Page
Purchase GNC gear from the Ohana Store!
Show Hotline 24/7 1-619-342-7365 or e-mail firstname.lastname@example.org
EmBand Brain Monitoring for Marketing.
Samsung Vibrant gets some Bug Fixes.
Facts on Japan Power Grid.
Wyse Pocket Cloud.
Where your Taxes Go.
Spaceship Airplane Style?
Playbook needs Crutches?
Judge gets down on WiFi Sniffing.
Righthaven getting Spanked.
Will BamBoom get BamBoom in the Kisser?
Cook that Meat!
NASA hands out 4 Big Checks.
Tagging Videos for Google?
Apple AirPlay Key Hacked.
Poker Sites Seized next Taxes Due by Players?
Michigan State Police extracting Cell Data!
Japanese Earthquake heard 900 miles away!
Google Video RIP Shortly.
P2P Streaming by Akamai.
YouTube Live for IOS
iPad Erase Board.
Get a Camera from Paris!
Tweetdeck in Play?
Demand Media gets Spanked again.
Apple App Ranking being Tweaked.
National ID coming your way soon.
Zillow to do IPO!
Paul Allen Part 1.
Paul Allen Part 2
The Power of Words.
Podcast: Play in new window
Podcast (video): Play in new window